Wednesday, January 29, 2014

While yesterday was officially the first day of Jewish History class, today was the first time we really got into the subject. We spent a good portion of the time discussing the documentary theory regarding the Tanakh, which proposes that the Tanakh actually had at least four authors, not one, and whether this fact changed the importance of this holy text. As students were offering their opinions, all I could think about is the question, "How can I make a decision about the importance of a text if I hardly know anything about it?"
Then Gertz went on to describe how little he knows about religious Judaism compared to learned scholars, and this gave me perspective about what I know. He's been studying Judaism for well over ten years, and it seems to me that he is a never ending pit of wisdom. And if he, by comparison, knows hardly anything, than that leaves me essentially without anything to go on at all. I'm still wondering how I can possibly try to understand and answer the questions posed to me without any background. I took away from all of this that I should try to learn more about the subjects we are studying in order to try to be able to better contribute and to grasp more information for myself.

3 comments:

  1. Your initial question is a great one. Your conclusion and how you came to that conclusion was even better. The more educated one is about a topic the easier it is to have an opinion. With that said, the study of the Tanakh, the land of Israel, and the people of Israel is a life long pursuit. Our heritage is one of constant questioning, lively discussions, and continuous education. However, it seems to me based on the the content of your and your teacher's blogs, you will acquired your own wisdom before you know it! Enjoy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have an idea on a great way to solve the problem of not knowing much about the Tanakh....study Torah! I know, I know, that's what you are doing, right? I am going to Torah study this Shabbat; same Parshah for every Jew, around the world...let's share one lesson/thought/idea/story you learned from this week's Parshah, deal?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree with you, Ben. I feel like I'm constantly trying to learn more, and every time I learn more I'm more and more amazed at how much more there is to know. I definitely agree with the first comment (I'm guessing a relative of yours) that this striving for knowledge is embedded deep within Am Yisrael. One of the articles I'm gonna give y'all this week talks about what traits cause people to be successful and it deals with this same issue. Check it out http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/26/opinion/sunday/what-drives-success.html?emc=eta1&_r=0. Sharing thoughts on parashat Trumah sounds like a great idea to me!

    ReplyDelete